Pros and cons of four transparent display technologies (video included)

Transparent displays - the future is now.

Transparent displays include any electronic screen which can show information on a transparent surface which allows you to see through it.

However, if you think this is new technology, think again. While most transparent technology has come to the fore since the millennium, it was being used as far back as the mid-20th century.

In this article, we’re looking at four types of transparent tech which include typical projection head-up displays (HUDs), LCDs, OLEDs, and transparent electroluminescent displays (TASEL). We’ll look at the pros and cons of each and show you how transparent display technology plays an essential part in our working lives and free time. An explanatory video by researcher Jose Rosa is available at the end of this blog post.

Transparent typical projection head-up displays (HUDs)

Of our four featured displays, we start with the oldest, HUDs. The HUD we’re referring to here is a typical projection head-up display. These use a projection system to project images onto a piece of glass in front of the viewer. A typical HUD contains three primary components: a projector, a combiner, and a video generation computer.

The first steps into creating transparent head-up displays can be traced back as far as 1937. However, it wasn’t until the 1950s, following perfections to the technology by the US and British Royal Navies, UK Ministry of Defence and, finally, the Royal Aircraft Establishment in 1958, that the first true projection ‘head-up display’ was incorporated into aircraft.

HUD of an F/A-18 Hornet
HUD of an F/A-18 Hornet

There is also an emerging technology called TASEL, which makes it possible to laminate displays in glass and show information without a projection system. However, as this a different transparent technology, we’ll mention this later in the article.

The most common transparent projection HUD is a display composed by a piece of flat glass used to project images in front of the pilot. This allows the pilot to keep their head up (hence the name ‘head-up display’) so they’re not distracted by looking down at their control panel for information during flight.

And HUDs are no-longer restricted to airplanes with cars starting to adopt the technology to assist drivers with critical information.

So, what the positives and negatives of the typical head-up displays using a projection system?

Pros

  • Drivers receive vital information within their field of vision and maintain concentration when driving
  • They don’t need to refocus their eyes between the information and outside the cockpit

Cons

  • Limited viewing angles
  • Complicated setups that occupy space and can be costly

This technology has been a staple for fighter pilots for decades. Although it helps pilots focus on the job and provides them with vital information, there are limitations too.

LCD displays

Why have we included LCDs as a transparent display when, at first glance, they’re not truly transparent? In fact, we’re only able to see the information on our monitors, such as laptops, with the introduction of a backlight and a reflector shield.

Take these away and we see true transparency of the LCD display - which is something Samsung did in 2012 with the production of their Samsung Transparent Smart Window.

However, to see the information, it needed the reintroduction of a backlight at all times to view it and, although this technology has been used to display products in stores, the need for constant light at the rear of the display makes its use limited outside of a strictly controlled environment.


Samsung Transparent Smart Window 2012

So, let’s look at the pros and cons of LCD displays:

Pros

  • Improved picture thanks to the use of backlit LEDs over a traditional bulb
  • Extraordinary richness and depth of colour compared to plasma screen displays
  • Multi-functional capability with TV displays also doubling as PC monitors
  • Cheaper to produce
  • 20-30% more energy-efficient compared to older bulb lit and plasma screens

Cons

  • Disappointing reproduction of black images
  • Restricted brightness due to the liquid crystal filter absorbing light
  • Limited viewing angle
  • Can suffer from screen lag and blur

LCDs are also one of the most popular screens on the market and this rise occurred early in the 21st century when liquid-crystal-display sets rocketed in popularity. In 2007, LCDs eclipsed sales of competing technologies like plasma, cathode ray tube, and rear-projection TVs.

They were thinner and lighter, easier to scale. And for the manufacturers, the cost of production was lower, so it’s easy to see how LCD displays quickly became a favorite with manufacturers and consumers.

However, with restricted brightness and need for a constant backlight, LCDs are limited to certain use cases.

OLED displays

Organic light-emitting diode displays, or OLEDs for short, are a step up from LCDs when it comes to transparent technology.  For starters, unlike LCDs, OLEDs do not require the use of a backlight or any other filters due to the use of pixels which produce their own light.

This means they’re thinner and lighter and have higher levels of brightness which is why they’re used to create displays in smartphones, tablets, computer/laptop monitors and portable games consoles.

So, what are the full range of positives and negatives for OLED technology?


LCD vs. OLED (click to see reference)

Pros

  • The plastic layers are thinner and lighter than the layers in LCDs
  • With no color filters in its layers, less light is absorbed resulting in a bright picture.
  • Richer colors and true blacks compared to any other TV display or monitor
  • Do not suffer screen lag or blur
  • Easy to produce

Cons

  • The organic materials used in OLEDs are affected by the environment, they’re sensitive to moisture and screen discoloration occurs if subjected to direct sunlight and heat
  • Loses brightness much faster than other transparent technologies
  • Pixels burn easily
  • Expensive to manufacture
  • Expensive for the consumer

OLEDs are ideal for devices like mobile phones, as consumers are likely to change these regularly, which is less likely with a bigger purchase, like a television.

However, while the positives of OLED technology are many, its list of negatives is quite stark. Issues with heat, moisture, loss of brightness, pixel burnout and expense to the customer, soon take away from its positives.

Transparent Electroluminescent displays (TASEL)

Lumineq’s Transparent Electroluminescent displays consist of a glass panel with a luminescent phosphorous layer and a circuit board. The circuit board contains the drive and controls which are connected directly to the glass panel making the panel light up.

It’s the most transparent and durable display on the market.

As it’s an inorganic display with solid-state design, it’s unaffected by environmental changes, meaning it will withstand extreme temperatures (high or low), humidity, moisture, vibration and shock - none of which affects its response time.

So, what are the pros and cons of transparent electroluminescent displays?

Pros

  • 85% transparency compared to similar displays which vary between 40-60%
  • Rugged, inorganic display which is unaffected by temperature, vibration, shock or humidity
  • Can be laminated in glass
  • Works even if the glass is cracked or broken
  • Touch-screen is in the same layer of the display layer
  • 360-degree viewing angle
  • 1 ms response-time regardless of temperature

Cons

  • Monochromatic images
  • Only available in two display colours (Yellow and Green)

The transparent electroluminescent displays are good solutions for transportation vehicles such as cars, buses, trucks, trains, trams, boats, and airplanes because they can be laminated in glass and turn windows/windshields into information and functional displays.

TASEL displays also have transparency of up to 85%, which exceeds the automotive industry requirement of 70%.

It’s viewable from all angles, is visible in all types of weather conditions and is the only transparent display capable of working in the most extreme environments, from the freezing temperatures of the Arctic winter to the blistering heat of a desert summer.

However, due to the limitation of monochromatic images, transparent electroluminescent displays shouldn’t be used as entertainment screens in vehicles - they should be used to display only the most critical information in the eye-line of the driver without distractions. 

Lumineq is also working hard on bringing more colors to our electroluminescent displays and looking at more ways in-glass technology can be used.

Science slam by Jose Rosa in the ImmerSAFE project

This comparison of different transparent display technologies is conducted by the Ph.D. reseracher Jose Rosa for the ImmerSAFE project. The project stands for "IMMERSIVE VISUAL TECHNOLOGIES FOR SAFETY-CRITICAL APPLICATIONS". 

The future – and beyond.

Each transparent display has its positives and negatives, and they’re all fantastic ways to showcase transparent display technology at its best when applied in areas which suit their purpose perfectly.

HUDs are ideal for planes and cars, however, Lumineq’s in-glass displays rival HUDs, doing an equally good job with the bonus of it using less space and costing less to implement too.

LCDs are perfect for catching the eye of customers when used in window displays, while OLEDs really come into their own in mobile phones.

Lumineq’s transparent electroluminescent displays are ideal in transportation vehicles, heavy machinery, such as tractors, and optical devices, like range-finders and night-vision goggles.

To read how in-glass technology is making giant strides in optical devices, read our post ‘Bring augmented reality to optical devices with transparent displays’, or to find out more about Lumineq's transparent electroluminescent technology, contact us today.

Download eBook Top 5 guidelines for designing transparent vehicle displays

As exciting as these unlimited possibilities are, they also create a new need for understanding and embracing the benefits of see-through displays. The eBook from below will provide you with ideas, inspiration, basic guidelines and industry examples for designing transparent displays for vehicles – from cars, tractors, and ships to aircraft. 

https://lumineq.beneq.com/download-lumineq-ebook

Contact Beneq

9 + 2 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

Contact Lumineq

3 + 2 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

Proceed to download

9 + 6 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.